Where to Eat in Shipshewana: Top Picks

By Angie & Jeff

August 25, 2026

If you make a purchase through an affiliate link on our website we might earn a small commission. There is no additional cost to you. Any and all Amazon purchases through our links can be helpful to us regardless of what you ultimately choose to purchase. Clicking through our links, and coming back to click through our links again each time before you start your shopping on Amazon, is a way you can help support our website and help us keep writing quality articles for YOU. We appreciate each and every one of you and we thank you for your support. ~ Angie & Jeff

Our time in Shipshewana, IN was hosted by Visit Shipshewana. The words in this article and the opinions we share are 100% ours.

Food is an important part of the Shipshewana experience. You can enjoy a hearty Amish-style meal, pick up a freshly baked treat, watch a local specialty being made, or stock your cooler with foods made by nearby producers. There’s a reason we saw repeated mentions of bringing your stretchy pants for your visit in their tourism materials!

For this article, we focused on places we actually experienced to confidently recommend. This isn’t intended to be a directory of every restaurant in the area. Instead, these are the places that stood out to us and the food experiences we think are worth making time for.

If you’re planning your first visit, you may also want to start with our Ultimate Things to Do in Shipshewana Guide and Where to Stay in Shipshewana. Both can help you build a trip that you will remember for years to come.

And if you’re trying to keep your trip affordable, don’t overlook the role food can play in your overall budget. We break down what a Shipshewana weekend can cost in How Much Does a Weekend in Shipshewana Cost?

Blue Gate Restaurant: A Shipshewana Classic

If you’re looking for a traditional Amish-style dining experience in Shipshewana, Blue Gate Restaurant is one of the easiest places to start.

We enjoyed the buffet during our visit, which gives you the chance to settle in for a hearty meal rather than treating lunch or dinner as simply a quick stop between activities. The food leans into the home-cooked comfort food that many visitors associate with Amish Country, and the pies deserve special attention.

If you spend much time in Shipshewana, you’ll certainly hear about the local specialty, Amish peanut butter. We were pleased to see this local favorite right on our table like a condiment offering us our first chance to try this local treat!

The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, making this a particularly easy choice when you’re traveling with a group or simply want a relaxed meal. And, if you’re enjoying a show at the Blue Gate Theatre, they are conveniently located right in the same building to make for an easy dinner and a show evening.

Amish Kuntry Fried Pies: A Food Experience Worth Watching

Some food stops are memorable because of what you eat. Others are memorable because you get to see the work that goes into making it.

Amish Kuntry Fried Pies falls into both categories.

During our visit, we learned about the operation from Marlon Miller, who started making the pies in-house before the business grew into its current shop. Today, the production is on a very different scale. The shop can produce roughly 500 to 550 pies an hour, with around 2,500 pies made in a day during typical production.

That takes a team. Marlon and his daughter work alongside six employees to keep the operation moving.

The pies have become part of the food identity of Shipshewana, and stopping for one is an easy way to add a distinctly local experience to your day. In fact, don’t just get one. Trust us. You’ll want more later!

Legendary Slices: A Good Pivot in LaGrange

Shipshewana is the center of this trip, but some of our favorite food discoveries came from taking a short drive into the surrounding area. You can learn more about area day trips in our article The Best Day Trips from Shipshewana.

One example is Legendary Slices in LaGrange, about a 15-minute drive from Shipshewana. The drive itself is part of the appeal. You get to leave town and enjoy the rural scenery, with horses and farm animals along the way, before arriving in LaGrange’s charming downtown.

We originally planned to eat lunch at Lindner’s Tavern, but on our Saturday visit it didn’t open until 4 p.m. Rather than change our plans entirely, we pivoted to Legendary Slices. (We did get to Lindner’s Tavern later in our visit, so stay tuned. Worth a stop, too!)

That turned out to be a good decision.

We met Lori Mast, the owner, who had recently celebrated the restaurant’s first anniversary under her ownership. We also found an excellent lunch deal, making it a particularly appealing option for travelers looking for a budget friendly option.

Lindner’s Tavern: Worth the Drive

Lindner’s Tavern on Main in LaGrange is another restaurant we would recommend adding to your list.

We tried the smoked pork, corned beef, and brisket, and the smoked meats were a highlight of our visit. The brisket was particularly tender, while the homemade chips and fries made excellent additions to the meal. We also enjoyed an impressive burger.

The restaurant itself has a beautiful space and a relaxed atmosphere that makes it a fun place to spend some time. We were charmed to notice products from Bloomfield Lavender Apothecary in the women’s room. This is a wonderful local collaboration of two businesses we really enjoyed. You can read more about area businesses like Bloomfield Lavender Apothecary in our post Unique Businesses in Shipshewana, Indiana: Passionate Owners.

Area Bakeries Tip-Come Early for the Popular Items

A bakery stop belongs on any food-focused Shipshewana itinerary, and Foltz Bakery has the history and reputation to make it worth your time.

During our visit, the donuts had already sold out, which is useful information if a particular bakery item is high on your list. We did get to try the sugar cookies, and they were excellent.

The bakery has a long history in the area, adding another layer to the experience. This is the kind of place where timing matters, especially if you’re visiting during a busy period and have your heart set on a particular item.

We also have Shawna Rae’s Sweets and Treats on our list of places we would happily return to. Her cheesecakes alone are worth the road trip!

And Blue Gate Bakery is on our list for a future visit. That’s one of the nice things about building a Shipshewana food itinerary. You don’t have to fit everything into one trip.

The Black Sheep From Scratch Kitchen: Worth the Wait

Speaking of Shawna Rae, if we had to name one meal from our Shipshewana-area visit that we would still be talking about long after the trip, it would be The Black Sheep From Scratch Kitchen owned by the multi-talented, Shawna Rae.

In fact, this was one of the best meals we’ve had anywhere. That is a pretty strong endorsement from two people who have eaten in a lot of places all across the country and world!

The Black Sheep is only open on weekends, which makes it an especially good option to keep in mind if you’re visiting Shipshewana on a Sunday. We actually highlight it in our Unexpected Things To Do Near Shipshewana on Sunday, because of the often repeated advice to avoid visiting the area on a Sunday. (Spoiler alert-we disagree.)

You may have to wait for a table. We did. But trust us, it’s worth the wait.

The menu evolves based on what’s available locally, so what you see during your visit may not be exactly what we experienced. That’s part of the fun. Rather than trying to create a menu that never changes, The Black Sheep takes advantage of its local food connections and lets the offerings evolve.

And whatever you order, we’re betting you’ll be happy with your choice.

We aren’t even big wings people, but the smoked wings completely won us over. They were that good. We also tried the Michigan Olive Burger, a Dill Weed Burger special, and the broccoli salad, and every bite delivered.

The portions were extremely generous, too. We left with a hefty box of leftovers that turned out to be perfect for a late-night hotel snack. That’s a win in our book, especially when you’re traveling and a great dinner can effectively become two meals.

Jeff also appreciated the craft beer selection, and the night we visited, a singer-guitarist was performing on the patio. The live music added another layer to an already fun atmosphere and made the wait and meal feel like part of the evening rather than simply a stop for dinner.

Scherger’s Jams & Jellies: A Small Shop With a Local Story

Scherger’s Jams & Jellies produces Amish-made jams and jellies, with the products made right here in Shipshewana. The business has been around for nearly two decades and is now being operated by the second generation.

What makes this stop interesting isn’t just the product. It’s the story behind the business and the fact that you’re visiting a specialty food maker rather than simply picking up a jar from a grocery store.

The products are also sold online and through Amazon, but visiting the retail shop gives you a chance to connect the product to the place where it is made and even enjoy some samples!

Yoder’s Meats & Cheese: Fill the Cooler

If your idea of a great travel meal includes taking some of the local flavor home with you or enjoying a picnic, make time for Yoder’s Meats & Cheese.

The business has roots going back to the family’s cattle operation, with the retail location established by a previous generation. Today, the family continues to raise cattle and works to emphasize quality and locally sourced products.

Their meats include smoked specialties, and the business also carries cheese from Amish communities in other Midwestern states. Other dairy products are sourced locally, while buffalo meat comes from Cook’s Bison Ranch.

We also learned about the family’s approach to raising cattle, including using horses to work the cattle rather than relying entirely on machines. It’s one of those details that gives you a better understanding of the philosophy behind the business.

Yoder’s isn’t necessarily a traditional restaurant stop. Think of it as part of the food experience of the area, especially if you’re staying somewhere with a refrigerator or kitchen and want to bring some local food home.

People drive for hours to stock up here, so if you have room in your travel plans, this is worth considering.

E&S Bulk Foods: The “Amish Costco”

You don’t have to sit down in a restaurant for food to be an important part of your Shipshewana experience.

E&S Bulk Foods is one of the best examples.

We heard it described as the “Amish Costco,” and once you see the scale of the operation, the comparison makes sense. This is a major bulk food destination, not a tiny country store where you pick up a few souvenirs.

The business is now in its third generation and has been operating for about 80 years. The scale is impressive. E&S has seven checkout lanes and is expanding to ten at the new store. The operation made roughly 1,100 pounds of noodles a day, and last year more than 18,000 take-and-bake pizzas were sold.

We also learned that the bagging room filled more than a million bags last year.

Those numbers tell part of the story, but walking through the store is what makes the experience click. It’s a place to browse, stock up, and find foods you may not normally see at home.

E&S can also be a practical way to save money on some meals while still enjoying local food. Our budget tip for a visit to E & S is to peruse the bakery area for day-old items that will be marked 50% off. We bought some day-old whoopie pies and they were a bargain at 50% off and tasted wonderfully fresh to us!

Ben’s Pretzels & JoJo’s: Easy Snack Stops

If you love soft pretzels, you’ll have two excellent options to consider in Shipshewana: Ben’s Pretzels and JoJo’s Pretzels. We enjoyed both, and each gave us another opportunity to try the local favorite treat: Amish peanut butter.

You can find JoJo’s inside the Davis Mercantile, making it an easy stop while you’re exploring the shops. We turned our visit into a light meal with a delicious chicken salad sandwich, a chocolate strawberry shake, and, of course, pretzels. It was a satisfying combination for a light lunch.

Ben’s Pretzels has its own stand-alone location in town and is another excellent option when you’re looking for something quick and satisfying. We also noticed their food stand at the Shipshewana Flea Market. Whether you’re grabbing a pretzel as a snack or building a light meal around their delicious pretzel pockets, Ben’s is another stop worth adding to your Shipshewana itinerary.

Acres Away Winery: A Memorable Meal With a View

Acres Away Winery in Ashley, Indiana, isn’t a restaurant, but it absolutely belongs on our list of memorable places to eat around Shipshewana. In fact, we had another one of our most memorable meals of the entire trip here.

We enjoyed the wood-fired pizzas and a pretzel that is truly bigger than your head, all while sitting on the outdoor patio with a great glass of wine in hand. Just feet away, a wildflower garden added to the setting, with vineyard rows and rolling farm fields stretching beyond it.

It’s the kind of meal where the setting becomes part of the experience. You’re not simply grabbing dinner and heading to the next stop. You’re lingering over your food, taking in the views, and enjoying the slower pace that makes this part of Indiana so appealing.

We also enjoyed getting to know Shane Christ, the owner of Acres Away during our visit. His passion for what he’s created here is a big part of why this stop has continued to show up throughout our Shipshewana article series.

There’s a reason for that: Acres Away wowed us.

If you’re willing to make the drive from Shipshewana, we’d absolutely recommend adding Acres Away to your itinerary. Check their current schedule before you go, since hours and food offerings can vary, then give yourself time to enjoy the patio and the setting rather than treating it as a quick meal stop.

Don’t Rush Through the Food Stops

Some of our favorite memories in Shipshewana happened around a table, not just at attractions.

That’s really what we want you to take away from this guide. When you’re planning your Shipshewana visit, don’t think only about where you’re going to eat when you’re hungry. Think about which food experiences will help you understand the place you’re visiting.

Enjoy fried pies from a unique Amish honor shop.. Browse the shelves at E&S. Pick up something from a local bakery. Sit down for a home-style meal. Take some locally produced food home with you.

Those experiences add another layer to a Shipshewana trip, and they can be some of the most memorable parts of your time in the area.

For help planning the rest of your trip, continue with our Ultimate Things to Do in Shipshewana Guide, find the right Where to Stay in Shipshewana: Our Top Choices, and see our breakdown of Cost of a Weekend in Shipshewana: What to Expect. And if you’re still wondering what makes this small Indiana town worth a visit, our articles Unforgettable Amish Country Indiana Experience and Unique Businesses in Shipshewana, Indiana: Passionate Owners brings the larger story together.

Related Shipshewana Guides

If you’re planning a visit, our other Shipshewana articles can help:

Ultimate Guide to Things to Do in Shipshewana.

Cost of a Weekend in Shipshewana: What to Expect.